‘The Following’ Season 2 Teasers: “The Second Chapter Will Change Everything”

“I’ve stared into the face of evil twice,” says Ryan Hardy in one of four new teasers for The Following season two. “Once I put him in prison, the second time I put him in the ground, but as I try to move on there’s still that speck of doubt, a phrase in my mind: ‘The Greatest trick the devil ever played was convincing the world he did not exist.'”

Each new teaser sets up the second chapter (or would that be the third?) in the battle of wits between Ryan Hardy and the most definitely not dead serial killer Joe Carroll. While it’s unclear if Fox learned anything from the first season’s general over-the-topness, the trailers are all spooky in their own right. Watch them all below. Are you going to be watching The Following‘s second season?

The Following season two premieres January 2014 on Fox.