The Office Season 9 Review “The Farm”

Those people still lamenting “The Office” spin-off that could have been got a taste of what might have been in store for them this week with “The Farm,” which featured footage taken from that aborted pilot. As it turned out, from the looks of things, it would have been a weird, wild ride.

It was fun seeing long-lost Roswell actress Majandra Delfino as Dwight’s heretofore unknown sister. I heard she went off to pursue her music career, but then she sort of dropped off my radar for a while. I always fall for the snarky sidekicks (i.e. Ksenia Solo, Aubrey Plaza, and once upon a time, Zooey Deschanel, before that sort of thing became commercially acceptable) and she was a particularly memorable one on that show that I always thought would hit it bigger than she did. Maybe this newfound exposure will help with that. Her role was a bit underwritten, admittedly, but that’s why they call ‘em pilots, folks.

We’ve met others in Dwight’s clan over the years, but it’s always fun to see them in their element, as we did here. This time around, it revolved around the death of Dwight’s aunt, who was apparently sort of a surrogate mother for him, while his actual mother was more of a surrogate aunt, according to the man himself. I loved his rejection of Jim’s condolences: “Keep them!” And the dirt-tossing ritual was funny, too, as Dwight went around throwing dirt on everyone, sometimes unsuspectingly.

Also putting in a return appearance was Todd Packer, played by David Koechner, of Anchorman fame, among many other comedies. He was supposedly in town in service of his enrollment in both AA & NA and was there to make amends with…well, pretty much everyone in the office. His apologies were hilariously terrible- for instance, to Pam-Pam & her “Pam-Pams,” he said: “I am so sorry I objectified you and personified your breasts,” then added, to the breasts: “Sorry, guys!”

Except that he actually intended no such thing, and was instead on a mission of revenge and gave them cupcakes laced with either laxatives or drugs- sometimes both. I loved the montage of Andy and Kevin’s shenanigans while zonked out of their gourds, especially the clothes-switching that culminated in a Hammer-style dance from Andy. Good stuff.

But the meat of the episode belonged to Dwight, of course. The funeral was hilariously awkward, with brother Jeb driving partially into the freshly-dug grave, then hopping out and wrestling Dwight; and another group doing a drive-by in a truck, complete with eulogy. Yep, that was none other than Alan Ruck, aka Cameron from “Ferris Bueller” in the driver’s seat. I assume all concerned at the funeral would have been on the show, had it actually become one. Well, save Oscar, who correctly observed of the Schrute clan, “They’re a descriptive people.”

I almost fell out when Dwight fired two shotgun rounds into the corpse to make sure his aunt was dead- it’s no wonder the NBC executives passed! But I thought it was all funny, if somewhat dark stuff. Maybe they should have downplayed the more twisted elements on the front end- it’s possible it might have scared the NBC brass off. But I loved it, personally. And that dialogue! Where do I begin?

Dwight: “The only thing we’re planting here is dead bodies.”
Jeb: “That’s fine, ‘cause they’re not going to grow.”
Dwight: “Thank God they’re not. Because we don’t want to make zombies.”

And his “flirting”- and boy, do I use that term loosely- with Esther was also brilliant, not in the least as he’d clearly said it before, if you noticed Mose mouthing along with the words.

Dwight: “Well, if you can snap two chicken necks with a single motion, why use two motions to slaughter those chickens?” I’m not even sure what that means, and I still laughed.

Okay, one more: this one when Dwight lamented that Jeb had become a pot farmer, and he talked about Jeb’s former dreams of planting glory.

Dwight: “He used to talk about growing a peanut-grape hybrid. One plant, one sandwich.” Would that it were so, Dwight, because that sounds awesome!

So, a solid episode all around. You can’t go wrong with Dwight, IMHO, and as this was mostly made up of his potential spin-off, it was a lot of fun. I can’t wait to see the rest of the lost footage on the inevitable DVD of the final season. If it’s half as funny as what we saw here, it should be a hoot.

What did you think of “The Office” this week? Would you have liked to see “The Farm” become a series? Do you still think there’s hope, somehow some way? (Hey, they’re resurrecting Veronica Mars- crazier things have happened.) Did you enjoy Packer’s antics, or would you have rather seen more of Dwight’s? Let me know what you thought in the comments!

Comments Comment Policy

Please make sure to read our comment policy before posting a comment.

  • diggz

    You’re insane. This was easily the worst episode of The Office ever, and quite possibly the worst episode of television ever.

    • basilfawlty

      You’re right this was an appalling episode, worse than anything in S8,and is by far the worst episode of the series. It showed the reasons why the Farm was cancelled, and I did not want to see Todd Packer again one of the worst characters in the series.

  • Curt

    The Todd Packer stuff went nowhere and aside from the Kevin/Andy montage, there was no actual pay off with the cupcake stunt (in a well written version of this weak script, Jim would’ve devised a clever way to get revenge and Packer would’ve left a a disgrace all over again). Dwight’s family was too large for any of those characters to be fleshed out successfully, and the sister just came across as a weak copy of Pam. The Schrute clan was only ever funny in either references where you’re forced to imagine people or scenarios, and were both individually and collectively intolerable in this large dose. Backdoor pilots rarely ever do much besides frustrate and bore the audience who has tuned in to see the regular cast. In my opinion, this one was no different. NBC was wise to pass. Can we please just finally let “The Office” go out gracefully, folks?

    • Curt

      Edit: “The Schrute clan was only ever funny in either references where you’re forced to imagine people or scenarios, or in occasional short-but-sweet on screen cameos.” [sorry for lack of clarity there]

      • Mark Trammell

        Okay, wow! Lots of disagreement here, so this will be a blanket reply to all the negativity. Like I said in the review, there’s a reason the Dwight-centric stuff stayed a pilot, and I acknowledge that. It’s pretty weird, left-of-center stuff, and always has been. The Dwight-related stuff is something that either makes the show for you or amounts to random weirdness you can overlook most of the time, so long as they don’t focus on it too much. It’s clearly not for all tastes, and I get that.

        Had they actually made this into a show, it would have firmly remained a cult-oriented show with admittedly limited appeal. I think NBC recognized that right away, and, as a network that could use a hit, didn’t see one in something that oddball. I don’t think it’s fair to point a finger at the characters as being not fleshed out, as that was something that happens over time on a new show.

        It was meant as an introduction to some new faces, and it functioned exactly like a pilot should function, which is to say, as a sampling of what one can expect for the future. And from what was seen here, this was never going to be a huge hit, so NBC passed- and they were right to.
        That said, I have left-of-center tastes. I like deadpan humor, and black comedy. Dwight has always been my favorite character, and I was thrilled when I heard he might get a spin-off. I wasn’t disappointed in the slightest by the results, but I 100% get that’s it’s not for everyone. It’s certainly not “The Office”- nor was it trying to be.

        I have mixed feelings about the Packer character, too, but I liked the drugged-out montage. Sue me.
        All of that said, if they had spun any other character of this show off, it woud have been a half-assed “Office” at best. You really want, say, a Jim & Pam show?
        I can see where people would want to let it just die with at least a little dignity, but ny sense of humor is warped enough that I would have loved to see a Swight-centric spin-off. That’s just how I feel, enough said.

        • Curt

          Actually, it is a fair criticism to say there wasn’t enough time to flesh out that many characters, given that they turned what WOULD have been a full pilot episode into half of a regular “The Office” episode. Doing so meant there was going to be even less time to respectfully set up these new characters in a newly established premise. The smarter moves would have been to either air “The Farm” in its original state to see if audiences would go for it, or junk the whole thing entirely.

          Sorry, but it just did not work.

          • Mark Trammell

            Yeah, I mentioned that in the review, when I pointed out that some stuff had to have hit the cutting room floor- and that I’d like to see it. But yeah, it isn’t fair to dis the character writing this early in the game regardless. If it had actually happened & become a show and a few episodes in you had that same criticism, that would be completely valid.
            As for the rest, like I said, it’s just one person’s opinion. You completely have a right to feel differently. I just bristle a bit when people get all “I’m right & that’s just the way it is!” I think it’s better to say: “This didn’t work for ME” you know?

            But I get it. Even i know enough to know that it wouldn’t have been for everyone- and I thought the idea of a bunch of execs getting a whole episode of “The Farm,” and being like “WTF” was hilarious, and it sort of made me like it even more!
            What would have been the point if they did it & all of the sudden made Dwight all accesible and sitcom-friendly in a way he isn’t even on “The Office”? I would have WANTED it to be weird, or else why bother?
            From what we saw, it toatlly was, and I love that they kept it true to Dwight’s character, regardless of what they would have been up to with the other cast members.

            • Curt

              Who said anything about trying to make Dwight sitcom-friendly or accessible? You’re on a tangent now and it tells me that you in fact do not “get it.” It’s also very clear that you have a problem with people disagreeing with you.

              Criticising the episode as we have is indeed fair. Just because we disagree with your assessment doesn’t mean we’re “dissing” or being unfair. The B story was weak compared to the caliber of material they have proven themselves capable of producing. Forcing it into the mix only weakened what could have been a decent pilot for a separate series. As a result, the episode failed to maintain the regular tone of the series and was a let down – perhaps not for you were clearly aching for further exploration into Dwight’s little universe – but definitely for myself and for others who have breezed through here.

              If the producers of the show want to prove some of us wrong, perhaps they need to include the “untampered” version of the pilot for “The Farm” on the season 9 DVD and let audiences decide for themselves if the idea is worth reviving.

              • Mark Trammell

                LOL. I just said (see below) that I didn’t care! I just like getting comments, period- good or bad. I agree that only an unfettered look at the full pilot, minus the “Office”-related stuff would give us an uncompromised look at what they were truly going for. But I didn’t have that, I just had this episode, and that’s what I went by. I liked the material on display, and I’ve thoroughly told you all why at this point.

                But, yeah, to reiterate, I could care less if any of you disagree- and many of you do. I get paid either way! Hell, at this point, I’m just enjoying the debate!

  • kensch

    I haven’t laughed as hard in a long time during a The Office episode as I did during the scene when the people were suffering the after effects of the cupcakes. From Phyllis playing with dolls, to Clark going caroling, to Stanley holding up 4 fingers, it just cracked me up. Kevin’s reaction was good too, although I didn’t much care for the scene with him and Andy. I normally can’t stand Todd Packer, but he was pretty funny this time. Also thought the Farm parts were reasonably good. Dwight’s relatives and friends were strange and eccentric, but mostly likeable. I liked the beaks of a crow courtship thing, the girl in the truck talking about going to get yarn, and the music.

    • Mark Trammell

      I guess we’re in the minority! But I feel ya.

  • seandroid

    This truly was the worst episode ever.

  • dpc1212

    I thought this episode was pretty dang funny. I found myself laughing out loud several times, especially when Dwight was thrown the shotgun and he pumped 3 shots into Aunt Shirley……..out of kindness. However, ‘The Farm’ would have been a lousy spinoff. I’ve always like Todd Packer though the story died with a whimper. I agree that it’s time for the Office to come to an end.

    • Mark Trammell

      The shotgun thing was SO funny…and the look on Oscar’s face. Maybe it’s bc I’m also a “Walking Dead” fan, but I’m accustomed to that sort of thing- guess most people did NOT feel the same way! Oh well. To each their own.

  • Office fan

    Guys Have to remember all the Todd Packer stuff was filmed much later after the Farm was not picked up. This had been edited down..it was a make shift episode.. the farm stuff was shot in August-September while the Packer stuff was shot in late December early January. Not a great episode by any means but the season has been off….they aired this episode because they had it done and in the can already..series finishes out in April through May..Im glad the Farm was not picked up but for one shot deal this was fine..If it would have been picked up Dwight would have been done in the office and on the farm full time.

    • Mark Trammell

      I couldn’t agree more with your overall assessment of the season, and I’m not just saying that. Obviously, I’ve reviewed the whole season & it’s been up for everyone to read, and the fascinating thing has been the way the critical tides have shifted over the season. When I started, I was highly critical, and everyone was all like: You’re being awfully hard on the show, you know? It’s not THAT bad. Now it’s the polar opposite! Now people are like: You’re not hard ENOUGH on the the show, you know? LOL.

      But yeah, I was aware of it being a failed pilot, obviously. I mention it in the article, but I’m not sure it was necessarily common knowledge until you were enough of a fan to really actively follow the show. In fact, I think I found out because I was speculating how they could continue the show as a spin-off and was like, Dwight would totally be the way to go, and someone was like: uh, that IS the way they’re going to go- do your research! D’oh!
      As, I try to reiterate stuff if I’m not sure if it’s common knowledge, and this was a perfect example. Some people just like to rant and rave, though. You get used to it & just learn to let it slide most of the time. But I try & defend my position if it seemed like people want to have a rational conservation about it, you know?
      To that end: Thanks for the comments, everyone! Even if you don’t agree, I appreciate you taking the time to do it!

Find out more about The Office, by selecting one of the following options.

X

+ Click to expand