Supernatural Season 8 Review “Trial and Error” – Sacrificing or Surviving: Who Will Win?

Supernatural (CW) - Trial and Error

In this episode of Supernatural, called “Trial and Error,” Kevin discovers some startling news and Sam and Dean go on a quest.

First of all, how fun was it to revisit Crossroads Demons, Hellhounds, goofer dust and all that fun stuff again. It was great to see the boys tackle something so familiar but, thanks to Kevin, have at least one more weapon at their disposal. The Winchesters in Holy Fire-doused glasses? Me likey.

Secondly, I think my word limit is going to stop me from saying everything that I want to say about Dean in this episode. And Sam, too, for that matter. But let’s start with Dean first. We saw last week that Sam was embracing the Men of Letters bunker much more enthusiastically than his big brother, but really Dean just had to do it in his own time and in his own way. Dean’s method was to settle down and nest; putting things up on his walls and cooking a real meal for a change. It was almost too bad that Kevin came up with the Trial, because I would like to have seen Dean enjoy it for just a wee bit longer.

Speaking of the trial, I could see that Dean was excited to have what looks like a sure-fire way to close the Gates of Hell, but it never occurred to me that he was once again planning on a suicide mission. Silly of me, I know, but I thought his new enthusiasm for his home and settling down would make him less self-sacrificing. Turns out I was wrong. In fact, it seems like getting into that bunker may have precipitated his decision and subsequent speech to Sam. It was as if seeing Sam getting all that knowledge proved to Dean that Sam was the one who needed to be saved, and not Dean himself.

Which leads me to Sam. Dean’s speech to Sam gutted me, but Sam’s speech took those guts, mixed them around a little bit and then stomped on them for good measure (sorry for that image folks, perhaps I’ve been watching too much of The Walking Dead recently). Sam telling Dean that he was the best hunter he’d ever seen and declaring that he too wanted to close the Gates of Hell – but he, more importantly, wanted to survive it – was beautiful. I love that Sam didn’t let Dean baby him and was there to save his big brother when the time came. I was kind of looking forward to seeing Dean go through the Trials, but I am excited to see Sam go through them now. Knowing that he’ll be fighting live and not just to sacrifice himself for the greater good will make it that much more gratifying to watch.

My favorite bits..

Okay seriously, where does Kevin live that the sun is up at 5:00am in January???

Wow, you know you’re working too hard when you give yourself a nose bleed. Poor Kevin.

Dean making himself at home and setting out things important to him. The guns I could’ve predicted, but the pic of their mom was a nice surprise.

“I’m nesting, okay?”

Sam discovering that Dean was a good cook.

“Something wrong?”
“Guess.” – Yeah. that’s pretty much a given for the Winchesters

Kevin telling the boys that he might have had a small stroke, but it also might have been worth it.

“Come here, you smelly son of a bitch.”

Dean happily offering to bathe in Hellhound blood if it meant closing the Gates of Hell.

“Yeah, you had me at ‘weird.’”

“I miss my room.” – Aw, poor Dean.

Dean talking to the horse. Too cute.

“I want to kill a Hellhound and not die. How about you?” – Sam’s got his priorities straight.

“Impressed?”
“I do like a man who can handle his meat.” – Ah, so many jokes, so little time.

“Keep it coming, Ken Doll.”

The look on Sam’s face when the family said Crowley’s name.

Dean referring to Holy Oil as “Jesus juice.”

The old man asking Sam if he knew anything about hunting. Ha!

Dean in glasses. That is all.

Wondering if there was a demon in Ellie.

Whoa, Dean turning down a romp in the hay?

“Yes, I can. You wanna know why? Because it’s what I do. And buddy I’m the best.” – LOVED hearing that come from Dean.

Dean’s entire speech about how he knew one of them was going to die and he wanted it to be him so that Sam could go on and have that perfect life, because THAT would be Dean’s happy ending. Gah. *rubs heart*

Wow, I haven’t heard that song in a while.

Our first real look at a Hellhound. Awesome!

Hellhound hallucination Dean COMPLETELY freaked me out, but kind of in a good way. Is that wrong?

“So you’re Crowley’s bitch, I guess pets really do look like their owners.”

Sam coming to the rescue.

Looks like Dean’s plan is ruined now that Sammy got himself a Hellhound bloodbath.

Sam confirming that Dean had indeed had worse injuries than a scratch from a Hellhound.

“I want to slam Hell shut, too, okay? But I want to survive it.” – YES! A Winchester who actually wants to live after saving the world.

And now Sam’s entire speech to Dean…..I can’t…..he just…..No words, people. NO. WORDS. *rubs heart some more*

What did you think of this episode of Supernatural? Got any favorite bits or least favorite bits of your own? I’d love to hear from you!

Follow me on Twitter @mokibobolink

Comments Comment Policy

Please make sure to read our comment policy before posting a comment.

  • Chased

    After all the years following this show, rearranging my work schedule if it meant missing a coveted season premiere or the resolution of a cliffhanger, I feel like I need to call in sick over a death in the family. It’s just not worth it anymore.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jennifer-Lundstrom/1406965972 Jennifer Lundstrom

    Both the boys’ speeches were awesome! Fandom is ready to rally behind Sam and see them both survive now! It was also a fun set/location.

  • Jessica Breaux

    Hi Michelle! Great review. I agree with everything you said. I read a few spoilers prior to the episode airing and found out that Sam would be the one taking on the trials. I must admit that at first, I was kind of disappointed. It’s not that I don’t love Sam. I do. But the poor guy has been through enough already what with going to hell, losing his soul, having a mental breakdown, etc. I wanted Dean to do this because he’s felt like he’s failed on so many occasions, and this was an opportunity for him to feel like he’s done something right. Also, I thought that the trials would be an excellent opportunity for Jensen Ackles to stretch his considerable acting chops. However, after having watched the episode, I think Sam is the right choice to take on these trials because he’s got to save Dean.

    Dean’s fatalistic approach to how closing the gates is going to end is completely understandable coming from him. Nothing in his life has ever worked out well when it comes to surviving saving the world. But it’s not just that. Dean has always had a much bleaker outlook on their future than Sam. Dean even said at one point that it either ends bloody or it ends sad, but there is no happy ending for them. Dean deciding to make closing the Gates of Hell a suicide mission didn’t surprise me at all because that’s what Dean does.

    Sam, on the other hand, has always been more hopeful than Dean when it comes to happy endings. The happy ending may not be a house, wife, and kids. But for Sam there was always life after hunting. Dean needs that right now. He needs Sam to help him see the light. He needs to believe that there can be life after hunting. He needs to believe that not only does he have something worth living for, that HE is worth living for. Dean has always had self-esteem issues and those issues generally tend to manifest themselves into Dean’s over-eagerness to sacrifice himself for his family and/or the greater good. Dean tries to hide it with bravado, but Sam has always been able to see right through him. Sam knows when Dean needs to be pulled back from the ledge, and we’ve seen him do it before. Sam can help Dean, if Dean will let him.

    I also have a feeling that once they find the angel tablet, Dean is going to have to go through the angel trials. Sam needs to survive these demon trials so that Dean can see that none of these endeavors have to be suicide missions. He needs to see that it is possible to save the world and live to tell about it. I have no doubt that Sam is going to need Dean in order to make it through these trials. And when S9 rolls around (yay!) maybe we’ll see Dean taking on the angel tablet trials. And he’ll need Sam to help him make it through that. Because that’s what family does. They believe in you in when you don’t believe in yourself. And they hold you up when you’re too beat down to hold yourself up.

    • tvmonkey

      Dean’s kind of stuck in an endless cycle of playing the marty and feeling sorry for himself. His growth this season will hopefully come from seeing light at the end of the tunnel, not taking everything as a personal slight on himself, realising that others have free will too and that he is not responsible for everyone and everything. Dean is is own worst enemy and its felt like the character has been stuck on blah since season 5. Time for that to change. I’m hoping Sam shows Dean the light you know inbetween trying to complete the tasks. Both of them are going to need to apply everything they know as hunters and MoL to complete them and they will need wach other more than ever.

      • Jessica Breaux

        Agreed

  • LordoftheNight

    Yet another great episode.

    Dean has come a long way but in the end he doesn’t think much of himself. Sam has always been the smart one and that is true, I do think Sam is smarter than Dean. But Dean is the truly brave one, the one who survived Hell, Purgatory and who has shouldered every burden that his family has placed on him and is still the best hunter in the world. I agree with Sam, Dean is the best there is and probably the best there ever has been. That he believes in Sam to do the trials is a sign of how far these brothers have come, back in S1 Dean wouldn’t have accepted Sam’s answer and would have looked for a loophole.

    Sam too has come a long way. He’s realised that he doesn’t want to be a hunter forever and I don’t think anyone can blame him for that. But as a Man of Letters he can be a hunter in the fashion he is best at, research and lore, and perhaps find that apple pie life he wants once more. And of course Sam will be the one to close the gates of hell forever. Demons have been screwing with him since he was 6 months old, and now he can finally get the ultimate payback. It’s fitting.

    And of course, The Hellhound. We’ve finally seen them after 8 and a half seasons and…. Oh. My. God. THAT THING WAS AWESOME!! I thought they were scaly but the shadow-dog form is waay cooler, and that image of it standing above Sam and snapping at him just before Sam opens it up from snout to crotch is just one for the show’s best moments reel. I really hope this is not the last we see of the Hellhounds, and that we still might see Growley at some point.

    Favourite bits:

    Dean’s room. It looks like an armoury…

    “Trouble?”
    “Guess.”

    Kevin off-handedly mentioning he may have had a stroke. Need to get Cas in there to do some healing asap.

    Dean’s comment about hot dogs being made of ground up hooves and pig anuses. And then saying that’s not a bad thing. I think it is!

    “Don’t OD.” Great advice Dean.

    Dean talking to the horse. It’s not like the Cat Dean, it can’t talk back.

    Dean and Ellie discussing the family. A Christmas album for dogs, the absurdity is what makes that funny.

    That dinner scene. If I were Sam I would have unhinged my jaw after listening to them talk to each other. And their inability to remember Crowley’s name, and thinking that he’s English.

    Dean wearing nerd glasses. Even he can’t make those immense things look cool.

    Ellie calling Dean Clark Kent. He’s more like Tony Stark, but broke.

    Dean and Sam holding a family hostage. And Dean’s comment about his being the best. He really is.

    Dean having a real face to face with a Hellhound for the first time. “So you’re Crowley’s bitch huh? Guess pets really do look like their owners.” Ahaha! Wish Crowley had been there to comment on that.

    Sam opening the Hellhound up and having a blood shower. Badass moment.

    “I’ve had worse.”
    “He’s had worse.” And Sam just standing there covered in helldog blood.

    Sam’s speech to Dean. Heartwarming and a moment that in my opinion proves why these two will stand by each other forever, and that Sam still looks up to Dean despite all the hardship they’ve both endured.

    Again a really great episode. Looking foward to next weeks, the sneek peek of which had me laughing so hard that I just couldn’t stop for a few minutes. :D

    • Jessica Breaux

      I don’t think Sam is smarter than Dean. I think they’re equally smart, just in different ways. Sam is very book smart and does well with research. Dean is much more practically smart and smart in terms of strategy. Essentially, they compliment each other.

      • tvmonkey

        Just like Dean isnt a better hunter than Sam, they’re equally good hunters. Dean just enjoys the pysical side of it more while Sam likes the research part more. Also Sam is just as tactically smart too, given that it was his plan that actually worked when all Dean wanted to do was summon a cross roads demon.
        Difference is Dean needs people to tell him how good he is while Sam just gets on with it.

        • Alcippe

          True, they are both smart, Dean solves the mystery instictively and is street smart and Sam is book smart and analytical and they compliment each other.

  • ptjackson

    Best moment for me – seeing them both in glasses – yeah, I’m shallow. But, they looked so darn good……

    Ok, on a serious note, I had this terrible urge to reach through the screen and give Dean a big hug after his speech. He had me in tears. I started out a Sam girl, and lately have been a Sam girl and Dean girl, but after this episode, I think I have finally transferred totally to the other side and am now officially a Dean girl.

    Great episode, looking forward to more, and can’t wait for season 9 either…..

    • http://twitter.com/Eutopia26 Jessica Breaux

      “Best moment for me – seeing them both in glasses – yeah, I’m shallow. But, they looked so darn good…”

      I may be shallow, but it’s still true. I don’t think it’s possible to put those two in an outfit or accessories where they DON’T look good.

      • ptjackson

        You make an excellent point! But I have a special thing for men in glasses….. 8-)

  • MauraHT

    They’re back, my boys are back! They’ve bonded like the old days and are hunting the baddies again! Super episode–full of excitement, humor, and monsters and tugged at the heart as well! How ’bout that hell hound??!! Awesome, totally awesome. The only thing missing was Bobby–still want Bobby back….

Find out more about Supernatural, by selecting one of the following options.

X

+ Click to expand