Revolution Season 1 Review “The Plague Dogs” – And We’re Down a [Spoiler]

Revolution (NBC) The Plague Dogs Episode 4 (5)

This week on Revolution, ‘The Plague Dogs’ should have been called An Hour of Unrelenting Gloom. Charlie’s kidnapped, Danny escapes…and is recaptured, Maggie dies, Rachel is tortured. Quick, someone crack a smile before their tears cause a flood.

I’m not sure how to explain my feelings about Revolution without sounding horribly negative, which isn’t my aim. There’s nothing fundamentally wrong with the show — good premise, decent actors, great visuals — but it’s just so flat and dull, even when it’s supposed to be thrilling.

‘The Plague Dogs’ sees Charlie, Miles and Nora meeting up with Maggie and Aaron as planned. They’re soon joined by the personality-deprived Nate, who Miles finally catches following them. But before they can determine exactly why he’s following them without, well, doing anything, they have to escape a pack of feral dogs. Holing up in a diner seems like a good idea, up until Charlie is kidnapped by the man who ‘owns’ the dogs.

He’s yet another victim of this post-event world, a man who lost his daughter to something that would previously have been completely treatable, and who wants company. Of course, the fact he’s sort of crazy and trusses up Charlie with an booby trap primed to take her out sort of makes us less sympathetic towards him. Miles and Nate kill him, but then almost kill Charlie in their attempt to save her. That, dear readers, was the most thrilling part of the episode, even though we knew she wouldn’t die.

The crazy guy did make a lasting impact on the gang, though. One of his dogs got Aaron’s leg pretty good, and crazy guy himself stabbed Maggie in the thigh — which caused her to bleed to death, despite the gang’s best attempts to save her.

Alright, so pro: my question about why Maggie couldn’t just take a ship home was answered. Apparently the various militias aren’t too big on ships and seafaring, because, I can only assume, no member of the militias knows about basic history and the way the world worked before electricity. You would assume that they’d want to trade goods with other countries, or maybe visit other countries to see if they can shed light on what happened to the power, but apparently not. Hopefully this will all be addressed in future episodes.

And the cons: why exactly was Maggie killed off? I’m not sure why she was in the show to start with, since she didn’t really do much, but there was no point in killing her now. Was her death supposed to have some sort of huge emotional impact? All we’ve heard about for 4 episodes is how so many people died, and how depressing life is, and that’s before we saw Charlie and her mom parting ways in a flashback (which was genuinely saddening). Maggie dying doesn’t really add or detract anything from the show. It was pretty pointless, in this reviewer’s humble opinion. (ETA: Okay, so it did convince Miles to stay with Charlie and co. Since I don’t particularly like him, I’m not convinced this is a good thing.)

Back at Chez Monroe, the big man himself has Rachel tortured (though we can only guess at what was done) before realising the best way to get at her is to imply she’s a bad mother. And to tell her that when Danny arrives, he’s going to torture him. The way the Rachel scenes played out, especially her going to the militia (and Miles) willingly, it’s looking as though either Ben did tell her more than she’s letting her on (as Monroe assumes), or she’s actually the one who knew about the power going out originally (which possibly contradicts the pilot episode, but would be more intriguing). It’s going to be interesting to see how things pick up once Danny arrives.

Though, to be honest, I don’t really want Danny to get there. My favourite part of this show so far is him and Captain Neville on their travels. Things were shaken up this week when Danny finally managed to escape, taking advantage of the commotion caused by a huge storm approaching (which everyone seemed pretty scared of, but why?). Neville recaptures him and the pair are left to wait out the storm, alone in a storm cellar. When the structure is damaged and Neville is trapped under debris, Danny has another chance to run, but Neville tells him that if he does, he’s essentially a killer too. Danny decides to help — and is recaptured again for his efforts.

Character-wise, Danny is my favourite on Revolution so far. He’s smart, he’s mouthy, and he’s not constantly emoing about something or other. Admittedly, it helps that he randomly ended up sleeveless and attractive at some point. Neville’s pretty awesome, too, but that can be explained by the character being played by Giancarlo Esposito, who is always fantastic.

In my idealised version of next week’s episode, the gang meet up with Danny, Neville and the militia and hijinks ensue. Alas, that may not be the case, but whatever happens, I hope the gang stop emoing, stop trekking through woodland, and finally get somewhere. Bonus points if ‘somewhere’ involves a more interesting plot.

What did you think of ‘The Plague Dogs’? Let us know in the comments below!

About The Author

A so-called student who spends more time than is probably healthy watching television and attempting to write novels. When she’s not watching reruns of The Golden Girls or creating non-sparkling vampires, she’s usually mourning TV shows of the past; mentions of Wonderfalls or The 4400 may make her maudlin. If you can remember Early Edition or 7 Days then she may marry you.

  • Anonymous

    I had watched the first few episodes of this show but didn’t dvr last night’s. 

    I thought I would read the review just to check and I don’t think I’ve missed much so I’m done with this show.

    However, thanks for reviewing and helping me with my decision.

  • http://twitter.com/SPN_ismylove Ally_A

    I personally love this show and can’t wait for more. I thought Maggie dying was very sad, but I think she had to die bc Maggie was their ‘mom’, and in order to bring Rachel back, I think the way had to be cleared. I’d like to see more of Miles and Nate teaming up, and more on Nate. I was not at all suprised Rachel turned herself over to Miles, the second he said it wasn’t his fault what happened to her, you could almost hear him thinking/saying ‘she was the one that turned herself in, what happened next was out of my control’. 
     

  • Littlewatercreek55

    Basicly this show is about a bunch of gutless wonders, incompetents and socialpaths.It doesn’t have one likeable character. have watched it for te last time.

  • Anonymous

    Character wise, Danny is a goddamn idiot. He’s too dumb to live, and really should just throw himself off a cliff or something.

    Charlie is worse though. Isn’t she supposed to be 22? She acts like she’s 16.

  • ptjackson

    I too am enjoying this show.

    I am very interested in what is going on with Rachel. How did she know that she was wanted by Monroe? What kind of promises were made to get her to voluntarily walk in? I will admit that I was wondering why it was necessary for her to “go off for supplies” and leave the family – that was just too stupid – until it was revealed what she was actually up to.

    What I find surprising is that characters who show themselves to be tough to torture can be brought down by telling them they are a bad mother or some such. Come on, that is not realistic IMHO.

    I totally agree with you about the back and forth between Danny and Neville – I am enjoying that, although Neville deserved to be left behind… I’m just sayin’…..

    Looking forward to next week and finding out more about Rachel.