The Good Wife Season 4 “And The Law Won” Review

The Good Wife Season 4 Episode 2 And The Law Won (4)

Things are not always what they seem. That seems to be the takeaway from “And the Law Won.” Alicia sort of made a new friend. Will’s case takes a rather unexpected turn. And I’m still trying to figure out what the heck is going on with Kalinda and her husband. This episode of The Good Wife was fairly standard fair, but it was fairly solid nonetheless.

A few observations about “And the Law Won”:

The case at the center of this week’s episode was a mother suing the city for the wrongful death of her son. An overzealous police officer pepper sprayed and tazored her son while he was participating in a war protest resulting in his death. It was Will’s first case back after his suspension ended, and he needed to win it. The win wasn’t just to prove that he’s back. The firm is also desperately in need of cash, and winning a big case against the city would help the firm a great deal. For a minute though, it looked like Will was off his game. Due in part no doubt to the jurors asking questions of the witnesses. I just want to pause for a second here and say what a bad idea it is for jurors to ask questions. I’ve served on a jury. And it’s frustrating to have questions that the attorneys don’t address. But people watch an episode of Perry Mason and they think they know the law. So they come to a courtroom trying to make things look like they do on tv. That’s not the way the law works. Also the judge is supposed to be impartial. He is supposed to ensure that the law is being followed. He is not supposed to help the defendant just because he presents a research study from Harvard. Ultimately, Will was able to negotiate a decent settlement. But quite frankly, it’s just a drop in the bucket for the kind of funds the firm needs.

I don’t understand why people are so concerned about Alicia standing by her husband. It’s her decision. One of the things this highlights is the judgmental nature of people. We judge other people by ourselves, and Alicia’s situation is a perfect example of that. She’s making the choices that are best for her. But because some people don’t believe they would make the same choices, they are having a hard time understanding hers. It’s human nature I suppose, but that still doesn’t make it right.

I’m not sure how I feel about Maddie just yet. One the one hand, she seems pretty straight to the point. She asks what she wants to know and she doesn’t seem to mince words. That’s one of the things I like about Alicia too. But on the other hand, I’m not entirely sure she’s being entirely upfront with Alicia. Basically, I trust her motives. She claims she wants to get to know Alicia because she (Maddie) doesn’t have many friends. But I don’t think she’s being entirely upfront about that. I think maybe she wants to get to know Alicia so she can find out information about Peter. A big deal was made of the fact that she only supports female candidates, and I think that’s what her play is. Use Alicia to find Peter’s weakness so she can knock him out of the race and get a female candidate on the ballot. Maybe I’m overthinking it, but it’s possible.

All in all, “And the Law Won” was a decent outing. I’m still trying to figure out what is going on with Kalinda and her husband. He’s creeping me out. What did you think of this episode of The Good Wife? And did anyone else get an Office Space vibe from the opening scene? Just me? Ok.

About The Author

Jessica is a lawyer by day and a Supernatural addict at all times. She loves all genres of tv and movies, but sci-fi is her favorite. She speaks in TV/film quotes and she watches way more tv than is probably healthy. She cut her TV teeth on Saved by the Bell, MacGyver, Matlock, and Star Trek. When she's not parked in front of her TV or computer, she can be found on the beach.