THE WALKING DEAD “Save The Last One” Review

THE WALKING DEAD “Save The Last One” Season 2 Episode 3 – Another good one. Wow. And with a twist I never saw coming, though I should have. I really should have.

We opened with an almost surreal shot of Shane (Jon Bernthal, better than he’s ever been) taking an electric razor to his head in a steam-filled bathroom scene that was one part Taxi Driver and one part Full Metal Jacket. It was unsettling, as unsettling as the show has ever been (and The Walking Dead pretty much has the monopoly on unsettling right about now). And that only gave us a tease…

Speaking of unsettling, how about not being able sleep because one woman is sobbing her eyes out and the other one keeps field-stripping her revolver? Just that combination of sounds had me on edge. I can’t imagine how Daryl (played with surprising nuance by Norman Reedus) was able to stand it. And really, he couldn’t. Daryl is yet another pleasant surprise, and it’s a treat just watching him open up a little, revealing the good guy within. I’m still sort of waiting for the other shoe to drop with him; he’s either got one hell of a personal demon to reveal… or his brother’s coming back.

(Or both. My money’s on the demon that also involves his brother.)

I’m probably in the minority, I realize, where most television critics are concerned, given the fact that I love this show unapologetically, and sure, and the show takes some lumps where character development is concerned. Personally I don’t see the problem. We’re literally nine episodes in. How much development do you want from people living hour-to-hour, constantly clinging to life? There is development—the basic question of live or die—there’s nothing more vital, and it sort of takes precedence over “traditional” character development ploys.

Nothing illustrates that better than Rick (Andrew Lincoln)’s talk with Lori (Sarah Wayne Callies); you can’t get a better, more tense scene from any hospital drama. The question of “should we even try to save him” is made real when we’re living in a zombie-infested world.

But for “character development traditionalists,” I guess we had what could be called the barest inklings of maybe / might be / could be romances, with Daryl and Andrea (it seems logical), and even with shy Glenn (Steven Yeun) and Maggie (the amazingly chameleonic Lauren Cohan). Both potential romances show promise, assuming we get some life from these characters… and I have the feeling if we get to see them to fruition, both will be completely different from the other. (Daryl and Andrea feels like a Bonnie and Clyde in the making, don’t it?)

But in the end you’re not going to top the “character development” whopper we got with Shane.

I called it, of course. Fat Otis was zombie chow. But that dude redeemed himself at least. Big time. He wanted to do right by Carl. R.I.P. big guy. But… I didn’t expect it to go the way it did. I’m not sure that’s even how it went down in the comic. Someday I’m going to read that motherfarmer.

So the show brought us back, full circle, to Shane and his radical transformation. Bernthal is just bleeping awesome, and I can’t wait to see what comes of this. Because you might excuse it by saying, “Well, he did it for Carl” … but maybe he didn’t.

Maybe he just knew it was life or death—it was him or the fat guy.

Reminds me of a shirt my wife owns: “WARNING: If Zombies Chase Us, I’m Tripping You.”

I guess replace “trip” with “shoot you in the leg so that you flail around and make enough noise to draw all the zombies to your hot, bleeding corpse.”

Shane’s obviously not coming out of this unscathed. You can’t make that kind of moral decision and come out clean (at least not on television). As Daryl succintly put it: “He made his choice. Opted out. Let ‘im hang.”

I hope they give us a healthy dose of Shane before the show opts out of this character. Man, I want years of this.

All you zombies, follow me on Twitter! That’s @Axechucker, you bunch’a Hooters!

Find out more about The Walking Dead, by selecting one of the following options.

Comments Comment Policy

Please make sure to read our comment policy before posting a comment.

  • Danny

    Lauren Cohan, amazing casting, loved her from Supernatural. Shane Shane, Shane…why not in the flipping head!!!! At least. Same outcome, less painful. Still twisted. Norman Reedus has been above and beyond when it comes to actors and roles. He needs his own Emmy award. This episode was great, wish we had a flashback and please find the girl already, but perfection and high fives all around.
    Love wife’s t shirt…so true

    • Axe

      The acting has been all-around spectacular. Hard to even find a weak link. Last year it was maybe Steven Yeun, but just from what I watched last night, he’s improved by miles.

  • Danny

    Lauren Cohan, amazing casting, loved her from Supernatural. Shane Shane, Shane…why not in the flipping head!!!! At least. Same outcome, less painful. Still twisted. Norman Reedus has been above and beyond when it comes to actors and roles. He needs his own Emmy award. This episode was great, wish we had a flashback and please find the girl already, but perfection and high fives all around.
    Love wife’s t shirt…so true

  • Danny

    Lauren Cohan, amazing casting, loved her from Supernatural. Shane Shane, Shane…why not in the flipping head!!!! At least. Same outcome, less painful. Still twisted. Norman Reedus has been above and beyond when it comes to actors and roles. He needs his own Emmy award. This episode was great, wish we had a flashback and please find the girl already, but perfection and high fives all around.
    Love wife’s t shirt…so true

  • Danny

    Lauren Cohan, amazing casting, loved her from Supernatural. Shane Shane, Shane…why not in the flipping head!!!! At least. Same outcome, less painful. Still twisted. Norman Reedus has been above and beyond when it comes to actors and roles. He needs his own Emmy award. This episode was great, wish we had a flashback and please find the girl already, but perfection and high fives all around.
    Love wife’s t shirt…so true

  • Danny

    Lauren Cohan, amazing casting, loved her from Supernatural. Shane Shane, Shane…why not in the flipping head!!!! At least. Same outcome, less painful. Still twisted. Norman Reedus has been above and beyond when it comes to actors and roles. He needs his own Emmy award. This episode was great, wish we had a flashback and please find the girl already, but perfection and high fives all around.
    Love wife’s t shirt…so true

  • Danny

    Lauren Cohan, amazing casting, loved her from Supernatural. Shane Shane, Shane…why not in the flipping head!!!! At least. Same outcome, less painful. Still twisted. Norman Reedus has been above and beyond when it comes to actors and roles. He needs his own Emmy award. This episode was great, wish we had a flashback and please find the girl already, but perfection and high fives all around.
    Love wife’s t shirt…so true

  • Bill

    I’ve been saying since early in S1 that Shane was a scumbag, yet a lot of fans keep defending everything this character does. Why didn’t he just put a bullet in Otis head? It was bad enough he shot him to save his own skin (did it to save Carl, my a**- he never saif anything to otis about doing it to save Carl), but why let him suffer like that. Being ripped apart by walkers is about as horrible a death as it gets on this show or any other. My guess is that he was too much of a coward to just murder the guy himself, but had no problem letting the zombies do it. Does anyone doubt now that he knew Rick was alive or at least that he might be when he took off at the hospital? Then he wanted to save his own skin and he wanted Lori and to be Carl’s new daddy. And in the previews, it sounded like he is still trying to put the moves on Lori. Jon Bernthal is a great actor. He is a very convincing a-hole in this show.

    • Axe

      I’m still not ready to call him “scumbag.”  I think he’s got … issues. 

      But I don’t think they’ll get better. I think they’ll get worse.

      As for how he murdered Otis, I think he wanted him alive, screaming, and flailing about to catch more attention.

      • http://www.daemonstv.com/ Sandie

        I think you’re right Axe. I thought Shane shot Otis in the leg so he would make noise and attract the zombies allowing Shane to escape. It’s cold blooded but that’s The Walking Dead, it’s life or death. You never know what you’re capable of until you are faced with it.

  • Robslack

    Shane was dead by this point in the comic, so they are free to take him in awesome, unexpected directions.

    The comic is definitely worth a read, it’s unrelentingly superb. And since the show has gone so significantly away from the comic story, you only end up getting broad-stroke spoilers.
    Thevdifference between reading a map, and actually driving there :)

    • Axe

      I did not know this! Dead already! 

      I need to get that comic book. Pronto. 

      • http://www.daemonstv.com/ Sandie

        Yes, Axe you need to get that comic book! I keep telling you. And this season is actually moving away from the comic storyline so you might be ok.

    • http://www.daemonstv.com/ Sandie

      Spoiler Alert! For those who haven’t read the comic book please don’t forget to warn before revealing plot points. :)

  • http://www.daemonstv.com/ Sandie

    This was an amazing episode, my favorite of the show by far. As someone who thought season 1 was just ok, season 2 is totally redeeming itself.

    I so did not see the Otis twist coming at all, but it was fantastic! I think I actually gasped.

    Oh and Axe just so you know this type of shocking stuff happens on a constant basis in the comic… so are you convinced to start reading it now? ;)

    • Axe

      I am convinced!  Amazon, take me away!

  • Brynn

    This episode was as dark as I’ve seen this show go. One side of the episode, you see Rick and Lori choosing to see hope for their son, and Glen learning to pray. On the other side… you see Shane letting his humanity go.  Yeah, there were definitely gasps in this household when the Otis moment came. I too went “Why not in the head at least, Shane??”

    I agree with Axe, I think it was so he would be a live zombie bait.  Live baits always attract more fish than dead ones.  Still. Gruesome. “Oh Shane…” was all we managed to say as we continued to watch.

    This show is GOOD.

    • Anonymous

      Well, okay. As long as everyone remembers explanation and justification don’t mean the same thing. Shane has made a string of bad choices and I can’t write them off as just the result of him having to deal with certain issues. Does anyone doubt now that he knew for sure Rick was alive when he ran from the hospital? And I’m not completely convinced he only wounded Otis just to make sure the walkers stopped to feed on him. I’m more inclined to believe the writers just wanted to add to the horror of what Shane did to make him just that much more of a controversial  figure. Regardless, what he did totally sucked and the “Excuses for Shane” team will really have to go into high gear after this episode. Anyway, if there is even a minute particle of decency left in this guy, he should be hearing Otis’ screams in his head for a very long time.

      I don’t know how, unless he confesses, but I really hope the others, especially Rick and Lori find out what Shane did. I got a feeling that a lot will be revealed before this season is finished, including Rick discovering that his beloved wife was making “jungle love” with his “best friend”  while he was fighting walkers left and right to find her and his son. I doubt the “we thought you were dead” line is going to keep Rick from losing it.     

      Also, did anyone else think Lori saying “stay” when Shane looked in on Carl had double meaning? I think the writers wanted viewers to question whether she was just talking about staying in the room and/or staying with the group instead of leaving like he had told her in the last epi he was going to do. Fictional or not, I would be very disappointed in this show if those two got back together, even briefly.      

      • Axe

        I think it would be a HUGE step back, if Lori somehow got back with Shane.  I can’t see it with any situation short of rape-by-gunpoint. 

        What Shane did is going to mark him forever. Somehow, some way, it’ll come out.

        And yeah, I think “stay” had double meaning. But I don’t think Lori knows Shane as well as she thinks she does any more.

        • Anonymous

          Well stated, Axe! I don’t see a Lori/Shane “re-hook-up” happening either. That would be sickening. 

          Shanee may hate himself for a lot for all the “bad choices” he’s made, especially tossing Otis ( I liked his character a lot more than Shane) to the walkers so he could save his own worthless skin. But I want everyone else to hate him too and see who the true Shane is – and the sooner, the better. Maybe, they are planning to have him go out in a blaze of glory at the end of the season by doing something incredibly brave to save everyone – a final act of redemption for all his past sins.   

          • Brynn

            As soon as they revealed what Shane did to Otis, I could only see two ways that Shane’s story would come to an end.  Either, as you mentioned, final act of redemption to save everyone else in his own death, or just a gruesome death like the one he dealt Otis as karma of his bad deeds catches up to him.

  • Gyasis

    Two things…First does anybody remember another cop drama whew a character named Shane drop a grenade in a good buddy of his lap a ran away? Yeah well welcome scumbag number two. Second this Shane’s character I predict will make easy gruesome decisions that he will hide for a little while but come out and terrify people at the end and I guarantee by that time he wont even care and channel his “a few good men” you want me, you need me speech
    Secondly the comic. No matter what the writers do that comic is untouchable….there are some things so gruesome that one scene still disturbes me today, and there is no way any network will allow that on tv. Read the comic and see what the phenomenon is really about, but I always wonder that if HBO did this than all that sex and violence in the comic would have translated very well to their network

X

+ Click to expand