CRIMINAL MINDS “25 To Life” Review

CRIMINAL MINDS "25 to Life"

CRIMINAL MINDS “25 To Life” Season 6 Episode 11 – Morgan is front and center of this episode of Criminal Minds as he tries to get a man out of jail a quarter of a century after he murdered his wife and daughter. Morgan is convinced the man is rehabilitated but when he murders someone else his reputation and career are put on the line as the FBI team try to clear the man’s good name and Morgan’s reputation.

I really like Criminal Minds. It is an easy show to watch, like Law and Order SVU: the characters are likable, the storylines are entertaining. You could watch an episode in season three, then skip ahead to a season six episode, and get what is going on. It’s forty minutes of pure entertainment. This episode was not forty minutes of entertainment. It was forty minutes of sheer blandness and increduality, capped off with a confrontation scene so ridiculous I almost had to turn off the television.

Morgan has never shown any pity for inmates, least of all those who are convicted of murdering their wife and young daughter. Why he would fight for this man’s release defied anything we’ve come to learn about his character over the past six seasons. It was utterly contrived. Morgan only learned of the man’s convenient innocence after he got him released from prison.

I have to say I did quite like the homage to the Shawshank Redemption in the montage of the man being released from prison and enterting the halfway house.

Beyond that, there wasn’t much to love. Agent Seaver, after starring front and center in last week’s episode, was reduced to a few bland lines this week. The revelation of the unsub seemed completely tacked on. I didn’t care one iota about the wronged imprisoned man and the emotional climax at the end of the episode fell flat because the show had not earned the dramatic moment.

It’s been a pretty solid season of Criminal Minds. It’s a pity the midseason ended on one of its weakest episodes.

What did you think of this episode, and of this series as a whole? Sound off in the comments below!

Follow me on Twitter @CiaraMoyna

Find out more about Criminal Minds, by selecting one of the following options.

Comments Comment Policy

Please make sure to read our comment policy before posting a comment.

  • Svetlana

    This is the worst epison in otherwise really good show

  • shirley

    Ciara,

    Totally agree with everything you’ve said. This was ho-hum at best.

    Who didn’t know the guy would be innocent? Who didn’t know Strauss would ride in on her broom? Who didn’t know the man and his son would get together in the end?

  • Lucy

    I did think it was a bit weird to be honest.

    I wanted to know where Hotch was?!

  • mo

    It was great show. you obviously don’t know his character at all. First off he was involved in this case 25 years ago, second he is very compassionate character, yeah he the first to cast doubt but if you really had watch, you have notice the unspoken scene where he review the case before coming to that decision. You only see what you wanted to see or not see.

  • roo

    Does anyone know the reason WHY James Stanworth killed the family? Because I honestly am confused about that.
    Other than that, loved the episode! :D

X

+ Click to expand