THIS IS ENGLAND ’86 “Episode 4″ Review

This Is England 86 (Channel 4) Finale

The fourth and final episode of Shane Meadows’ four part series THIS IS ENGLAND ’86 saw redemptions and reconciliations as England face off Argentina in the infamous ‘Maradona’s hand of God’ match in Mexico.

It opened with the trademark blend of drama and comedy; as director and creator Shane Meadows cuts from Combo and Shaun and Trev to Woody and Milky spooning each other as Lol looks on.

Then to Lol’s rapist father, mumbling to himself in the kitchen. Lol’s mother tries to talk to him, but he snaps at her at tells her (in a less PG rated way) to leave him alone. Lol’s mother is one of those women who would drive anyone mad; a man by her side is as necessary as oxygen.

Milky is a good guy, but his character in the television series is utterly flat, used only as a plot device so Lol can express her helplessness. If Lol and Woody are his best friends, why does he seem absolutely guilt-free about sleeping with Lol. I think Meadows tried to answer this in his conversation with Lol, but was I the only person who found it odd that he should be so eager for Woody to marry Lol that day.

I did like the scene where Woody and Lol confronted each other about hiding their feelings. It was very well acted, even if the quirk of a parrot in the background was annoying.

Trev tells Lol about the rape. I can’t help feeling manipulated. It is obvious Trev’s rape was constructed purely so Lol would have a reason to aggressively confront her father. As well acted as it was, it was sickening to watch, especially as a clip in a montage of Trev mouthing the event to Lol, Milky and Woody on scooters, Combo in the bathroom, over some music. And then, just in case the audience was not spoon fed enough sap, we switch to to Lol’s sister Kelly sleeping in bed with the father talking over her.

Combo returned to visit his mother, but was too late. His mother passed away. As Shaun brushes away tears it is clear that despite everything Shaun still thinks of him as a surrogate father.

Meanwhile at the church (oh yes, the wedding has been arranged), Lol is nowhere to be found. She has gone to confront her father. The scene itself was great: the single camera, the natural dialogue, the blocking. She then accuses him of being a rapist. She pulls a hammer out of her pocket, but he tackles her before she can use it. As he violently attempts to rape her, she picks up the hammer and bashes it over his head repeatedly, until his face is covered with blood. And whilst he’s still shaking, she hits him again, and he is dead.

Meanwhile, Combo comes to the house and breaks the door down. He then prepares to take the fall for Lol (whom, in the film, he harboured feelings for) and proceeds to sabotage the evidence; putting his and Lol’s father’s fingerprints all over the hammer, pressing Lol’s father’s hand to his face, choking himself with it.

Meanwhile, a newsreel shows the preparations for the England versus Argentina quarter finals. Lol, Kelly, Trev, Milky and Woody play poker together, the rest of the gang convene in the pub. Meanwhile, Combo is sent back to prison for manslaughter, redeeming himself, Shaun and Michelle have sex in the bathrooms.

And that it that. This Is England ’86 initially had me so thrilled it was almost like JK Rowling had announced an eighth Harry Potter. Then the second and third episodes provided a grating mix of comedy and drama, used rape as a plot device (twice) and ended with a predictable bloody death, redemption for Combo and a toilet tryst for Shaun. I loved the characters in the beginning; by the end most of them infuriated me. I know many people love love love This Is England ’86, but I am not one of them.

What did you think of the finale? Will you be signing the Facebook petition for another season, or are you glad to be rid of it? Let me know in the comments below!

Follow me on Twitter @CiaraMoyna

Comments Comment Policy

Please make sure to read our comment policy before posting a comment.

  • Jessica Miller

    I think this “review” should be re-named – a blow by blow account of the events of the episode in clumsy paragraphs isn’t a review. If anything is being “spoon fed” to us it’s your negative and narrow sighted comment on what has been one of the most powerful works of TV drama I can remember seeing.

    Some of the actors used in the film and this series were amateurs when cast so yeah some of the performances (Milky) can seem a bit awkward at times but this was Shane Meadows intention – realism over polished stage school “jazz hands” actors faking Midlands’s accents and detracting from the story.

    Of course the rape was a plot device, pieces of drama do tend to have them otherwise it’d just be scene after scene of everyone sitting around twiddling their thumbs. I think you’ve missed the point, the rape scene was sickening – he was a predator and I found it almost too hard to watch, this is the mark of an exceptional piece of film-making. Meadows didn’t protect us as an audience from the brutality of the attack anymore than Trev was – it was brave and necessary to strip the veneer of humanity from Lol’s Dad showing him for the animal he was.

    “Over some music” – the fact that you didn’t bother to comment on the soundtrack or in any depth the seminal pieces of football footage which set the tone of mid-80′s England with loving accuracy just further shows you didn’t get it, which is fine just don’t write a “review” which adds no comment or insight. And I severely doubt anyone who is thrilled over the prospect of another instalment of Harry Potter should be attempting to comment on something as raw as a Shane Meadows series, maybe you should stick to reviewing Hollyoaks episodes.

    • http://www.daemonstv.com/author/ciara/ Ciara

      Thanks for the comment!

      In fairness, just because someone did something with loving accuracy doesn’t mean they did it well. Though in the case of This Is England the production values were excellent, and the soundtrack was deadly.

      I wasn’t, by any stretch of the imagination, critiquing the acting. It was uniformly deadly. But seriously, what did you think of Milky’s storyline? Was it not a little too fake?

      The rape was sickening…the visuals of it at least. But I just did not think it was executed well in its integration to the plot.

      But hey, it’s my opinion. You have yours and I know there are LOADS of fans who share your opinions.

      I can appreciate it for its high production values, for attempting something different, for its brilliant acting and dialogue.

      And lastly (and most importantly): Did you dis Harry Potter? I think my heart stopped beating! :)

  • Rob Melia

    In the words of comic book guy from The Simpsons.

    Worst.Review.Ever!

    Thank you Jessica Miller.

  • Fingy

    I think anyone who can write a “review” criticising the writing of TIE86 would at least be able to form a more concise synopsis without starting 3 paragraphs with “Meanwhile”.

    • http://www.daemonstv.com/author/ciara/ Ciara

      That must be a record…I usually aim for five…but thanks for the feedback; any constructive criticism is welcome. I can always improve my writing :)

  • Steve

    Thats not a review:
    It reminds me of a rushed piece of school homework I would have done before bedtime or on the bus back in the 80′s…….
    And the teacher quite righty would report “Could do better”

    • http://www.daemonstv.com/author/ciara/ Ciara

      Funny…that’s almost exactly what I thought about the plotting in the show…

      Thanks for the comment!

  • Jeff

    I can certainly see where you are coming from on certain points, but I generally I disagree with your overall view.

    Milky as a character I thought was perfectly explained, I believe it was end of episode 1 that it explored how Woody, Lol and Milky had always had a kind of 3 way relationship and how close they all were. As adults of course that had begun to spill over into infidelity, but I dont think it lessened Milky as a character, he was stuck between a rock and a hard place in many ways, he loved Lol but knew ultimately that his love of their friendship (and that of Woodies) was greater so he backed off and accepted what he saw as the right thing to do.

    As for the rape scene/s I think you are dead wrong, they were incredibly powerful but I think made more powerful by not lingering on or going into detail of the aftermath, we didnt need to hear the clearly long harrowing conversation Trev had with Lol, it wasn’t important, we knew what it would be having been through the event with her.

    My only criticism of the series was that I’d have prefered episode 3 to have introduced combo earlier as he is one of the deepest and most interesting characters in the show and brilliantly acted by Stephen Graham. It would have been nice, for instance to see some form of finality or end brought to what happened between him and milky, did he still believe in those same views? Was he sorry? That was my only gripe.

    All that said everyone is entitled to an opinion, but I do think you somewhat missed the point in some places. For all its faults (it wasn’t as good as the film) it was far better than any other supposed drama aimed at the working class and dealing with similar issues.

    It felt at all times believable and that it was made with genuine love for the period and place, unlike say Shameless which feels like an awful pastiche of the working class made by people with no idea of the people or places and played for laughs, or skins which is just sensationalist nonsense. So yeah for all its faults it puts other similar programs to shame in my opinion.

  • Newtraal

    [Editor's Note: Comment removed because it violated our comment policy.]

    • http://www.daemonstv.com/author/ciara/ Ciara

      You’re right. I did have a laugh.

      I don’t understand why disliking this show makes me a fan of East Enders and Coronation Street (in actuality, I’ve never watch a full episode of either show, so I can’t judge the quality of them).

      I appreciate that you got a lot out of this narrative.

      I didn’t, so what can I do, lie? Say I thought Milky’s character was totally not flat, say that watching Lol glower for the last two episodes was utterly enjoyable, say that Combo’s redemption was like, so totally not contrived, that Woody was not irritating in the slightest as he ignores his fiancé (whom he left on the altar) whilst she’s clearly in a state of devastation.

      Nope, sorry, no can do. The plot moved from going nowhere in episodes 2 & 3 to going absolutely bonkers in the finale (bonkers in a bad way).

      But thanks for the comment!

    • Newtraal

      Yet you removed my comment because “Comment removed because it violated our comment policy.”

      What you mean is it questioned your egotistical review. You get to respond to it but I don’t (even though you have removed my post – and no doubt will delete this one). If you disliked my comment then fine – discuss it!, but removing an objection to your review …. Carry on, I won’t be visiting again, even if their were some very interesting posts and points for discussion before you slammed the hammer down. Fuck you and your site! I was just trying to discuss with others what the final show meant, but because I thought YOUR review was crap you delete it! I shall look elsewhere for an interesting discussion about this show

    • http://www.daemonstv.com/author/ciara/ Ciara

      If you read the comment policy (or learned basic manners) then you’d see that profanity isn’t allowed. Duh.

      As for discussing it: look at my previous comment.

    • http://www.daemonstv.com/author/sandie/ Sandie

      Newtraal – Please note that Ciara did not remove your comment.

      If you look at our comment policy you will see that profanity and personal attacks on a writer are not allowed.

      However we do encourage constructive criticism. Daemon’s TV is a place to share different opinions respectfully and love for television shows, not to attack writers because they disagree about a viewpoint.

      Any further offending comments will lead to comments being removed.

  • Daniel Tull

    My only problem with the episode was the short screentime of Combo. I really wanted to see him confronted by Milky or maybe attempt to reconcile, THEN to find Lol.

    Other than that I found the episode and series as a whole a compelling piece of work. As with the original the acting seems very natural, nothing seems to be scripted and Meadows finds a perfect balance between comedy and drama.

    At the same time I understand not everyone is going to enjoy it and the beautiful thing about this show is that it sparks debates and discussions that analyse it which at the end of the day proves only that it has succeeded in making an impact. Like it or not it has clearly impacted you in such a way that you have reviewed it and are now discussing it.

  • Danny

    i just saw it today and i’d actually have to agree with you in a sense, i would view the tv series as much weaker than the film, the film had a lot to do with the historical relevance of the difficulties of growing up at that time, whereas the tv show could have been set at any time and was more focused on more personal issues and really i couldn’t see that much of a link between the two.
    the character of Milky i thought was, nice guy and all but a bit of a dope, it was amazing how he didn’t feel too guilty for riding his best mates girlfriend, the rape scene with trev was really disturbing and to be honest i got the impression that they just made it so graphic for “shock value”, but saying that i thought Lol’s father was played very well, if a little bit too convincing as a rapist, i thought they wasted the character of Combo, they could have done more with Meggy and his son (who wrecked my head),

    the sub plot of gadget and trudy i thought was brilliant as was the one with Woody and his boss, and the reference to the warm-up of the england v argentina match (all about settling old scores) was excellently placed,

    all in all i was disappointed with the tv show in comparison to the film, and i hope they end it before it gets worse

  • Charlie

    I’m sorry but I have to completely disagree with this review!

    To start…Milky’s character is flat in the series. Please tell me how it differs from the film? Thats his character, laid back milky, you wouldn’t want 2 woody’s so he has to contrast. And to say he is guilt free! i think i was watching a different program…he loves lol and is so torn up with guilt that he wants things to become right again as soon as possible i.e. lol and woody to marry!

    The parrot adds humour! Humour is needed in such an intense series.

    I don’t think the audience were being manipulated…surely it was trying to say that once a rapist, always a rapist! and that often a rapist will take any opportunity to do it again. Sure it had to happen quickly but that happens when a series is so short! The rape scene could have been a lot worse and if people couldn’t watch the reality of what happens in real life they should have turned over when it became clear what would happen. And sorry but where was the ‘sap’???? sap is what you find in rom coms not This is England.

    I agree the scene with lol and her dad was brilliantly acted and filmed!

    I really think this has been the best piece of tv for a long time and Shane Meadows is a brilliant story teller/director! The characters are real, the story is gritty and hard hitting. The content is making people talk and think about the issues! that is what it is meant to do…it is not plot devices and audience manipulation. This soundtrack is fantastic. The actors are genuine and a lot of them havn’t done much else so i take my hats off to them! Especially those in the tougher scenes!

    It is so easy to criticise people’s work. I love this series and cannot wait for Shane Meadows next wrok.

    I like Harry Potter but it doesn’t challange me in any way. This did! I would be interested to know what you thought is a good tv series?

    Oh and if you havn’t ever seen the film please watch it…i would be even more shocked if you panned that!

X

+ Click to expand