Harper’s Island Victim #9 is…

J.D. Dunn "The Black Sheep" - Harper's Island

…J.D. Dunn aka “The Black Sheep”

This show is getting really crazy. Now we’re really getting into the slasher movie type storyline with the people “stuck” on the island. And J.D. was the latest victim this week, along with poor Deputy Garrett (the cop guarding the prisoners), and Cole Harkin, the “mysterious” man with his face half burned.

But of course the craziest thing had to be Henry coming out with bloody hands next to where J.D. was dying. This makes me think that one our readers and Harper’s Island fan, Dani (check out her blog here), might have been right all along about him. Although at the same time it seems like a pretty early time to reveal the killer’s identity. So let’s just say that I cannot wait for the explanation of the bloody hands next week.

Also doesn’t it seem like there are still a lot of people alive with only five episodes left?

Don’t forget that you can keep track of the victims here.

My pick for next week? Well, it should be getting easier, right? But it’s not. How about I pick Mrs. Wellington. I guess I’ll find out if this will be the one time that I get it right. Who do you think will die next?

Author: Sandie | June 8, 2009 | 10 Comments

Print This Page

Comments Comment Policy

Please make sure to read our comment policy before posting a comment.

silly

I’m pretty sure that the wedding planner has something to do with it all… she moved Wellington under the blade and had the lights turned on, she could have smashed the tea set, she knew the priest had been whacked, she commented that Richard had been given that room where Madison disappeared… she was startled by the fireworks and planted one to implicate JD…

and what’s up with the floor waxer? Everyone is fleeing the house and some guy is waxing the floor? Same guy who trims the hedges?
http://danitime.blogspot.com/ Dani

Thanks for the shoutout Sandie! I think you are right, though, it is awfully early for them to reveal the killer so the fact that they implied it was Henry probably means that it is not Henry.

However, since it seems to be “all about Abby” as JD put it, I am still of the belief that it is someone close to her. My thoughts are either on her dad, the Sheriff, or her former boyfriend Jimmy. Isn’t it a bit strange that he scared off the killer so long ago, knew she was hiding in the bushes and never mentioned it? Maybe he was working with Wakefield?

Silly also has some good ideas too though. All that stuff adds up to the wedding planner and maybe it will come out that she was having an affair with Abby’s dad or something a la Scream. I also agree about the floor waxing guy. I thought it was strange too. Also the fact that he never stopped to help the lady screaming about her child.
http://daemonstv.com Sandie

The wedding planner is a suspicious character.

I also had the same thought Dani had about Jimmy. I suddenly got very suspicious of him. As for Henry, he still could be the killer, they might be trying to throw us off his scent and then have a big twist in the end. Maybe Jimmy and Henry are in it together…

Oh and I didn’t even think about that guy waxing the floor, but now that you guys mention it, you’re right, it is weird that he’s around.
http://danitime.blogspot.com/ Dani

I thought of that as well Sandie. Maybe it is just because I am hoping Henry is the killer or one of them. Maybe they will show him early, discount him and then it will turn out it was him or him and another all along.

I love this show!
http://catherinette.wordpress.com Catherinette Singleton

I heart Harper’s Island!! Yay for slasher shows!!

The ending of the last episode was so freaking AWESOME!! Though it totally cannot be Henry as the killer. I’m putting my money on Jimmy.
http://danitime.blogspot.com/ Dani

Yay Catherinette is in the house! I must disagree about Henry though. He has a rather creepy smile. And if it is “all about Abby” it may be him. Or Jimmy. Or him and Jimmy.

Or someone else entirely.

I love this show!
http://daemonstv.com Sandie

I think the great thing about the show is that it just keeps you guessing. There isn’t one person that just stands out. Even Henry or Jimmy, it might not end up being either of them. I cannot wait for next episode!
http://danitime.blogspot.com/ Dani

That is exactly why I love it too! Saturday nights are now my favorite. How many episodes do we have left?
Hannah

I still have my wildly unbacked-up money on Cal with maybe Chloe complicit. It doesn’t seem right to me that they’re in their own little world of comic relief and getting engaged and just so happened to come good and not leave the island. Plus the British make excellent villains.

I also think the sheriff or Jimmy will be the last victim because it’s all about Abby and they’re such opposing (albeit truced) forces in her life.

As for who’s next, I think it’ll be Shane or someone else high up in the wedding party. I feel like Trish or Henry isn’t going to survive the whole show, and that there is no way they’ll off Madison now or ever. So I go with Shane or maybe Shea or Beth. Shea’s running all over the place looking for Madison so she might well get picked off.

All that said, now it’ll totally be Cal and/or Chloe, just so I’m back to square zero.
http://danitime.blogspot.com/ Dani

Hannah -

I agree about the strangeness that is Cal and Chloe. It didn’t really concern me that they were off having adventures and getting engaged at first as they had no clue anyone had died so to them it was a grand vacation. However, in this week’s episode, in the midst of killings and helping the wounded sheriff, they go off and have sex in the next room? And fell blissfully asleep afterwards? That was a bit much.

Isnt this also the first time we have heard anything of what Cal does for a living or is this just the first time I listened?